 |
|
Issue 009 · November 10, 2026 Closed on Wednesdays.In 1968, Wall Street drowned in paper and shut down one day a week to dig out. The card market is having the same problem. Also: this morning's inflation report came out missing its most important number. |
Happy Tuesday. This is Population Report, a letter about trading cards, collectibles, and the slow-motion collision between culture and capital. It's published by tash, which lets anyone buy shares of professionally managed indexes of the world's most iconic trading cards, the way you'd buy an ETF. This week is about plumbing: the unglamorous stuff underneath a market that decides whether anyone can trust it. About five minutes, with opinions you're welcome to disagree with. |
2026 Population Report The Lead Issue 009 | #01 GEM MT 10 |
|
|
Until the 1970s, owning stock meant owning paper: an engraved certificate that physically traveled by messenger every time you sold. By early 1968, NYSE volume was averaging about 12 million shares a day, and the back offices broke. Certificates got lost or never showed up, a "fail" in Wall Street terms, and fails piled up faster than anyone could clear them. From June 12 through the end of 1968, the exchange closed every Wednesday so the clerks could catch up. By 1970, roughly one in six brokerages had merged or folded, plenty of them simply from not knowing what they owned. The fix came in 1973, and it was almost insultingly simple: stop moving the paper. The Depository Trust Company locked the certificates in one vault and changed a ledger entry instead. If you own Apple stock today, the registered owner is almost certainly DTC's nominee, a firm called Cede & Co. Most people have never heard of it. Good plumbing is invisible. A graded card is a certificate. The slab and its label are how strangers agree on what's inside, which is why a card can sell for six figures to someone who has never seen it. Right now the system issuing those certificates is buried. PSA's grading backlog peaked at 12.4 million cards in July and was still 6.8 million on November 3, and when PSA reopened its $39.99 tier, the flood of new submissions slowed the drawdown. Volume outran the back office, same as 1968. |
6,800,000 Cards still in PSA's grading backlog as of November 3, 2026. Down from 12.4 million in July. |
|
Trust in the paper is cracking too. A collector says the PSA 10 Rayquaza he paid more than $660,000 for came in a counterfeit holder: real card, real label, rebuilt case. PSA hadn't commented as of late last week, so for now it's one collector's account. But notice what it describes. Nobody forged the certificate. They forged the envelope it travels in. October's FedEx theft, which forced PSA to deactivate thousands of cert numbers, was the same kind of problem. Our read is that the card market's DTC already exists, just in pieces. PSA, Fanatics Collect, and Alt all run vaults where cards can sell without leaving the building, and Topps now lets redemptions ship straight to one. A card that sits still only has to be checked once, at the door. That check has to be good (PSA's own vault sold a counterfeit One Piece slab for $18,500 this summer), but after it, the card never travels again and a trade becomes a ledger entry. Collectors who like holding their cards won't love that. But if cards are going to sit in a portfolio next to an index fund, settlement has to be boring. The big difference from 1973 is that DTC was an industry utility. Card vaults belong to companies that also sell the product, run the marketplace, or own the price data. Fanatics owns Topps, a marketplace, and a vault. PSA's parent owns the grader, a vault, and Card Ladder. Wall Street spent fifty years separating those roles, and cards are building them all at once. (Fair warning: tash's model depends on cards sitting in vaults, so weigh our optimism accordingly.) |
2026 Population Report THE BIG STORY Issue 009 | #01 GEM MT 10 |
The number that isn't there. |
|
|
This morning's inflation report has no year-over-year number. Last fall's shutdown meant nobody collected October 2025 prices, and you can't measure a year when one end of it is blank. September's figure was 3.7%, and economists' stand-in estimates for October land between 3.7% and 3.9%. What we did get was hotter than expected: prices rose 0.4% for the month and core prices rose 0.3%, both a tenth above forecasts. A December rate hike now looks close to certain, and Fed Governor Christopher Waller said this morning he'd consider a half-point move if core came in at 0.3%. It did. Gold, the classic hedge, is roughly where it was a year ago. Meanwhile, Card Ladder tracked $1.07 billion in card sales in October across 9.2 million transactions, its first billion-dollar month, at an average of about $116 a sale. That isn't proof anyone is hedging inflation with Pokémon. The game's thirtieth anniversary and the rise of live-selling apps explain plenty of it. The more useful lesson is 2022, the last time rates rose hard. Card Ladder's CL50, an index built mostly on modern stars, fell 23% that year after its pandemic run. Its pre-war index, cards from 1945 and earlier, rose 29%. Same hobby, same rates, opposite results. New cards with big print runs behaved like speculation. Old, scarce, well-documented ones behaved like a store of value. That split is showing up again. Collector Nation's October index has new releases down for a fifth straight month and about 40 points behind older cards. If December brings a hike, expect headlines that the card market is cooling. The more accurate version is that the speculative part cools, and the part that has been scarce and documented for seventy years holds up. That second part is what earns cards a place in a portfolio. |
2026 Population Report The Headlines Issue 009 | #02 NM-MT 8 |
|
|
The house sets the price. A Texan pulled the 1-of-1 Dylan Harper debut patch from a $25 digital pack on PrizePicks, then sold it back for $2.88 million. The money landed in his PrizePicks balance, where it could be withdrawn or spent on more packs and picks. The valuation matched the card's September auction result. It's a fascinating experiment in instant liquidity, where the platform facilitates the market, holds the inventory, and offers the buyback. Paid in Pokémon. A Texas sheriff alleges illegal game rooms in San Antonio paid winners in sports and Pokémon cards they could sell for cash next door. Nothing is proven yet. Still, being used as a cash substitute is a strange compliment for an asset. eBay leans in. eBay is cutting about 1,000 jobs while shifting resources toward collectibles and authentication. It handled roughly 59% of October's tracked card sales. Next week. Sotheby's offers 12 paintings from the Blaquier-Arrieta collection on November 18, with estimates approaching $450 million. A single van Gogh could bring $180 million. Twelve paintings, nearly half a billion dollars. Meanwhile, cards moved more than a billion dollars across 9.2 million transactions last month. We'll compare the two once the hammers fall. |
2026 Population Report Posts of the Week Issue 009 | #03 GEM MT 10 |
|
|
| |
 | Life and Football ✔ @LifeandBall | 𝕏 |
THAT BOYYYY SAID THAT!!!!! |
|
 | 73 ✔ @slicorey | 𝕏 |
Asked this girl in my class what school she goes to |
|
 | Filcrow ✔ @FilCrow_ | 𝕏 |
Pokemon in the hood
Made with @higgsfield |
|
 | Adam Schefter ✔ @AdamSchefter | 𝕏 |
Raiders No. 1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza will now take over as the starting QB following Kirk Cousins’ trade to Minnesota.
Las Vegas is 4-5, and Mendoza’s first two career starts will come against the Seahawks and Broncos, two of the NFL’s top defenses. |
|
 | ًً ✔ @enletritas | 𝕏 |
Gmail when I log in from another device |
|
 | 800.HL ✔ @degennQuant | 𝕏 |
Me in the shower, replaying the exact moment I should've taken profit and didn't |
|
| |
The best cards in the world, within reach.Buy shares of professionally managed card indexes. The same discipline as an ETF, applied to the world's most iconic cards. |
|
 Population Report is published by tash, the investment platform for trading cards. Read our sector thesis: The Census Asset. Nothing in this letter is financial advice. Populations cited are from public grading-company reports; prices from public sale records. © 2026 Tash Cards Inc. |
|